A Lack of Basic Text Formatting Skills

By Deane Barker • • tags: text • 4 min read •
Author Description

Most content creators have a lack of basic formatting skills, making it difficult to have them create well-rendered content.

AI Summary

This post discusses the author’s observations about the declining basic text formatting skills among people, particularly in digital communications. The author emphasizes the importance of these skills for effective communication and suggests that a lack of understanding can lead to misunderstandings in professional environments.

I’ve been working with content management for a long time, and there’s one thing that’s been constant: at some point, a user is going to write and format some text in some kind of control. How good are they going to be at this? Their level of skill here will go a long way in determining how effective content management can be.

When content management developers look at a domain of content, we tend to divide it up in our head – this data will go in this field, this data in this field, etc.

Some content can be broken up more than other content. Some is so structured as to be a collection of simple text or numbers in fields. Other content requires a larger area in which an editor can, well, edit some text – the body of the ubiquitous “text page,” for instance.

Often, you put WYSIWYG controls in these spaces, and let the editors have at it. However, what I’ve found is that even if you structure a text page as much as possible – break out fields for title, subtitle, author, summary, etc. – things break down pretty quickly in the body of the text page.

People just aren’t that good at formatting a page of text. It’s sad, but true.

Last year, I complained about the lack of skill the average user has with Word. I’ve done the same with FrontPage. How are WYSIWYG editors much different? You end up with about the same thing: really poorly-formatted text.

No matter how sophisticated the WYSIWYG editor, here are the things I see over and over again:

  1. No use of headings

  2. No use of bulleted or numbered lists

  3. Overuse of underlining and boldface

  4. No concept of whitespace

  5. Paragraphs that are way too long for the Web

  6. No awareness of the difference between a line break and a paragraph break

  7. No awareness of what terms should be hyperlinked, and where they should link

  8. No awareness of how images should be positioned

  9. A desire to center every heading, title, and subtitle

  10. Attempts to “hack” horizontal whitespace with tabs and consecutive spaces

  11. Overly large tables without headings, captions, or consistent spacing

(Note too that pretty much all of these things could apply to formatting documents in Word too. Text formatting and document structure is a universal computer skill.)

The bottom line is that you can implement the most beautiful design and sophisticated content management system in the world. But if the users have no concept of text formatting and no idea of how to structure a page of text, you’re just going to be throwing ugly blobs of text around.

I just launched a big project with Ektron CMS400.Net. This system is built around eWebEditPro, which is an excellent WYSIWYG editor – probably the best I’ve seen.

In training, I spent a lot of time working with users on how to format text. The results were mixed. I think they do it better than they did before training, but I still see a complete abandonment of formatting tools in a lot of the content they’re generating.

And all the tools are there – eWebEditPro rivals Word in its ability to format. Plus, we have eWebEditPro really dialed in in terms of available styles and tools specific to this organization’s content. But we still get a lot of bad formatting.

I’m not saying that all users have to be graphic artists or even great writers. But there’s a lot of usability difference between a poorly-formatted and well-formatted page of text. And all the WYSIWYG in the world isn’t going to move people from the former to the latter unless they’ve been trained on specifically how to do it.

So do we abandon WYSIWYG? No, it very much has its place. But unleashing WYSIWYG on your users is not enough – they have to be trained in basic document formatting.

I’ve never seen this training done in a universal, platform-independent manner. Document and text formatting in general is rarely addressed outside of specific platforms, and that’s a shame.

Links to this – The Four Disciplines of Content Management November 24, 2007
All of the disciplines put under the "content management" moniker can actually be split into four distinct groups.
Links to this – Crucial Microsoft Word Skills That Just Don't Get Taught July 22, 2006
My church is building a huge new addition , and part of it is going to be a computer lab. This means that I’ll finally have a nice spot to teach some free computer classes, which is something I’ve wanted to do for a long time. I got to thinking the other day what I’d teach, and I think there’s...
Links to this – What Content Management Won't Do October 15, 2006
Content management can do a lot, but there's a lot that it won't do, and you need to understand this before you implement. This is a reality check on the problems content management is not going to solve for you.
Links from this – The State of Microsoft Word in the Enterprise September 10, 2005
One thing that continues to amaze me is how poorly people use Microsoft Word, considering its dominance in business word processing. The “barrier to entry” for a Word user is extremely low – just open it and start typing – so very few people bother to learn how to really use it well. I spent three...
Links from this – The FrontPage Experiment Has Failed January 12, 2006
Can we finally admit that the FrontPage experiment has failed? You know – the promise that FrontPage will allow novice Web authors to create and maintain ( especially maintain) good, solid Web sites? Can we finally admit that this just isn’t going to happen? How many people know someone that is...