The Mystery of Dr. Fu-Manchu

Book review by Deane Barker tags: classic 2 min read
Updates
This content has been updated 1 time since it was first published. The last update happened .
An image of the cover of the book "The Mystery of Dr. Fu-Manchu"

This was the first of the Fu Manchu novels. It’s over 100 years old, and I’m trying to take that into account when I discuss it.

The book is written from the first person perspective of the British Dr. Petrie. On the first page, his friend Nayland Smith shows up at his house and tells him that he’s on the trail of the mysterious Dr. Fu Manchu. Smith has returned from Burma, where he was stationed.

Fu Manchu is presented as the ultimate criminal. The book was written during the Yellow Peril, when American’s were concerned that Asians were going overwhelm the country.

Consider:

“He is the greatest genius which the powers of evil have put on earth for centuries. He has the backing of a political group whose wealth is enormous, and his mission in Europe is to pave the way! Do you follow me? He is the advance-agent of a movement so epoch-making that not one Britisher, and not one American, in fifty thousand has ever dreamed of it.”

The book is super-racist – there’s no other way to put it. Asians are depicted as devious agents aiming to subvert the Western world.

For just a moment I realized fully how, with the place watched back and front, we yet were cut off, were in the hands of Far Easterns, to some extent in the power of members of that most inscrutably mysterious race, the Chinese.

The plot of the book is simplistic. Petrie and Smith travel all over England, trying to capture Fu Manchu. They’re aided by a beautiful woman who may or may not be a slave or accomplice of Manchu’s.

I was never quite sure of the motivation of Fu Manchu. At one point, he steals the plans for an “aero-torpedo,” which sounds like an early version of a cruise missile. Later in the book, it’s revealed that Manchu can make people appear dead then revive them (his expertise with chemicals and medicines is emphasized, as that probably fit the Asian exotic-ness of it all). I kept feeling like there was going to be a big reveal of some over-arching plot, but the book seemed content just being a series of episodes.

The book is a product of its time. The writing is a little elaborate, and the plot seems to be just one action or crime scene after another. Petrie and Smith are kind of like Holmes and Watson. My understanding is that Smith becomes the main protagonist in all the Manchu novels.

Of course, in the end, Fu Manchu escapes and the ending is left open. Clearly, Rohmer intended to write this as a series.

I’m glad I read it. I might try some of the movies. There were about a dozen throughout the 20th century – from the 20s through the 60s, staring different actors, made by different studios.

Update

Added on

The book Superspy Science talks about the deadly centipede used in the the James Bond novel Doctor No, and has this footnote:

An idea almost certainly stolen from Sax Rohmer’s The Insidious Dr Fu Manchu.

I was confused by the title, but I found a note in Wikipedia:

The novel was also published in the U.S. under the title The Insidious Dr. Fu-Manchu …

Book Info

Author
Sax Rohmer
Year
Pages
308
Acquired
  • I have read this book. According to my records, I completed it on .
  • I own an electronic copy of this book.
Links both to and from this – Fu Manchu June 5, 2023
Fu Manchu was the villain in a series of Sax Rohmer novels in the first half of the 20th century and continuing into films. In popular culture, he is considered an archetype of a “supervillain.” Generally depicted as Asian, with a mustache that extends downwards from the corners of his mouth. (The...
Links both to and from this – Yellow Peril September 16, 2023
This was the depiction of East Asians as an existential threat to the Western World, mainly during the late 1800s and early 1900s. Asians were used as antagonists in movies, novels, and comic books, often portrayed as criminal masterminds bent on taking over the world. This was partially due to...
Links to this – Dacoity December 13, 2023
This refers to “banditry” or “theft,” mainly in Asia. It’s an anglicized form of the Hindi word meaning “armed robbery.” “Dacoit” is the noun form.
Links to this – Syncope November 3, 2023
This is the official medical term for fainting or sudden loss of consciousness. “Pre-syncope” is the feeling that you’re about to faint. The most common form is “vasovagal syncope” which means you have a sudden drop in blood pressure which causes you to faint due to lack of oxygen to the brain,...
Links to this – Skein April 27, 2022
The extended/metaphorical definition in many cases is “things that can be interwoven.” Examples: “A difficult or complicated situation” “A web, weave or tangle” For example, plot threads are like skeins of yarn. I googled “skein plot” and I found a bunch of books and movies with it in the title,...
Links to this – Cathay September 16, 2023
It may stem from a Turkish word to describe an ancient ruling dynasty. Marco Polo used the word quite often when describing his travels.
Links from this – Superspy Science: Science, Death and Tech in the World of James Bond July 25, 2024
This is a great book that I sort of wanted to write. About a year ago, I made this comment on the James Bond subreddit, in response to someone who called out the absurdity of the villain’s plan: I would really like to see an examination of James Bond films (and other films) for poor engineering and...