Nomological Network

By Deane Barker tags: rhetoric, critical-thinking

This is an inter-related set of proof points to prove a hypothesis. It’s a little hard to grasp, but it basically means “a mountain of related evidence.”

From Oxford Reference:

A lawful pattern of interrelationships that exists between hypothetical constructs and observable attributes and that guides a researcher in establishing the construct validity of a psychological test or measure.

Two researchers coined the term in 1955, based on the Greek word for law. They stated that a nomological network of evidence for a point should generate testable hypotheses.

“Nomology” is the study of scientific laws. So a nomological network is a group of laws for an argument.

Why I Looked It Up

It came up quite a bit in The Parasitic Mind.

The author doesn’t strictly define it, but as an example he presents a set of evidence to prove that men generally prefer women with an hourglass figure. He provides seven proof points (example: “the hourglass figure has been associated with greater fertility and superior health”), but doesn’t stick to one discipline or methodology.

His points are all over the map – a “network of evidence” for his point. I think the author was saying that even though no single point completely makes the case by itself, all the points together form a solid argument.

He uses the phrase “nomological network of cumulative evidence” several times.

Links both to and from this – The Parasitic Mind: How Infectious Ideas Are Killing Common Sense November 1, 2023
The author of this book is very angry about misconceptions that people have and the fact that they continue to have them. He comes down pretty squarely on the political Right, but he never actually articulates a political position. He’s furious about “political correctness.” He’s also not a fan of...