Rebels Against the Future: The Luddites and Their War on the Industrial Revolution: Lessons for the Computer Age

TLDR: “Interesting, but about a very specific thing, and it gets a little preachy in the end.”

Book review by Deane Barker tags: history, technology, luddite 2 min read
An image of the cover of the book "Rebels Against the Future: The Luddites and Their War on the Industrial Revolution: Lessons for the Computer Age"

This is a history of the “Luddite revolution,” when textile laborers in central English destroyed machinery that was very rapidly taking their jobs. It’s where the general term “luddite” came from, meaning someone who refuses to adopt new technology.

I was surprised to find out that this all took place over a very short period of time, in a specific geographic location. It all happened from about 1811 to 1813 in the rural areas about Notthingham (a happy coincidence that this is where the fable of Robin Hood was also set). The action was quite condensed, but furious for those two years.

A band of textile workers loosely organized until the “command” of “Ned Ludd,” who was likely not a real person. They broke into textile factories and destroyed machines called “frames” (or maybe that was a part of the machine?). They did this because their livelihood was being completely obviated by these machines.

Several people died in the process – the factory owners began fortifying their factories and leaving armed guards there overnight. And as the Luddites were caught, many of them were sentenced to death and hanged.

The author is quite sympathetic to the plight of the workers, and explains how the only way of life – and, in many cases, the foundation of their communities – was being wiped out, leaving them completely adrift. Wages dropped through the floor, and many workers, families, and entire towns were forced into abject poverty. The situation was ripe for revolution.

But the violence eventually petered out, likely because there was just no stopping the advance of the machines. As they were destroyed in Nottingham, they were being built in London and bigger cities, and they were spreading all over the country (and, one imagines, the world). It likely dawned on the Luddites that their war was simply unwinnable.

At the end, the author provides some “lessons” from the Luddites:

  1. Technologies and never neutral, and some are hurtful
  2. Industrialism is always a cataclysmic process, destorying the past, roiling the present, making the future uncertain
  3. “Only people serving an apprenticeship to nature can be trusted with machines.”
  4. The nation-state, synergistically intertwined with industrialism, wall always come to its aid and defense, making revolt futile and reform ineffectual
  5. But resistance to the industrial system ,based on some grasp of moral principles and rooted in some sense of moral revulsion, is not only possible but necessary
  6. Politically, resistance to industrialism must force not only the “the machine question” but the viability of industrial society into public consciousness and debate
  7. Philosophically, resistance to industrialism must be embedded in an analysis – an ideology, perhaps – that is morally informed, carefully articulated, and widely shared
  8. If the edifice of industrial civilization does not eventually crumble as a result of a determined resistance within its very walls, it seems certain to crumble of its own accumulated excesses and instabilities within not more than a few decades, perhaps sooner, after which there may be space for alternative societies to arise

Clearly, this is some level of Left-win idealism (the author is a bit of a radical). Sadly, of course, any discussion of “morals” will wilt in the face of capitalism.

(See: The Human Connection and the Lack of Corporate Morality)

The book was written in 1995. I’d be fascinated to know how the author feels today, in the face of AI and other automation (he’s 87 now).

Book Info

Author
Kirkpatrick Sale
Year
Pages
336
Acquired
  • I have read this book. According to my records, I completed it on .
  • A softcover copy of this book is currently in my home library.
Links to this – Times Beach August 27, 2024
This is a former town outside St. Louis, Missouri that was abandoned by government order in 1984 after it was found to be contaminated with dioxin. A chemical company across the state manufactured an anti-microbial agent. Dioxin was a byproduct of this process. Incineration of this chemical was...
Links to this – Intellectual and Cultural Eras September 28, 2024
When considering ages or eras of history, framing is very important. The first thing you need to understand is that these time periods are wildly imprecise, for a couple reasons: (1) they naturally overlap, and (2) you need to decide the “altitude” from which you’re going to consider them. At the...
Links to this – The Riot Act August 27, 2024
This was an actual law enacted in England in the 1700s which allowed the police to disperse crowds that they felt threatened the social order. The Riot Act had to be “read aloud” to the assembled crowd to warn them of impending arrest. This was the exact text of the act: Our sovereign lord the King...
Links to this – Rialto August 27, 2024
The proper noun “Rialto” refers to the central district of Venice, Italy, known for his historical marketplaces and commerce. Over the years, “rialto” has taken on a general definition. When lower-cased, I’m assuming it just means “marketplace” or “commerce” in general.
Links to this – Dragoon August 27, 2024
This is sometimes used as a predecessor term to “cavalry,” though in my research, it mostly referred to foot soldiers who were transported to battle on horseback. The name comes from a common weapon in 17th Century Britain – a musket called the “dragon” – which was carried by these troops. Today,...
Links from this – The Human Connection and the Lack of Corporate Morality October 13, 2014
I own 25% of Blend Interactive , which is a significant percentage. This chunk of ownership binds me to this company, in the sense that I see the company as a sort of extension of myself in many ways. I’m not a minor owner – I’m a significant part of the day-to-day operations, and my input goes a...
Links from this – The Robots Are Coming
A blog about workplace automation I maintained back in 2016