Bookshops: A Reader’s History

Book review by Deane Barker tags: books 1 min read
An image of the cover of the book "Bookshops: A Reader’s History"

I really tried with this book, but I had to abandon it.

This is one of those books that doesn’t really have a point. It’s just a meandering journey through one guy’s love of bookshops around the world. He apparently visited 1,000 of them.

I read his Wikipedia page, where I found this:

He uses to [sic] remark the [sic] importance of bookshops in a post-digital era. He points out that people are reconnecting to the material.

Now, I’m not against that, but his writing style is wildly obtuse and even a little arrogant. He plays “inside baseball” a lot – makes references I didn’t get, and he talks about bookshops in pseudo-spiritual terms that just fall flat.

Don’t get me wrong, I like bookstores as much as anyone, but the writing was annoyingly pompous in places, and hard to follow.

Like, seriously – consider this quote:

The book will work this way: it will embrace the comfort of orderly reading and digressions and contradictions that disturb or threaten; it will re-create possible traditions and at the same time insist it only speaks of examples, exceptions from a map and a chronology of bookshops that is impossible to re-create, that is made up of absence and oblivion, suggests analyst and synecdoche, a collection of glittering shards and left over remnants from a history history of encyclopedia that can never be written.

…um, what?

I keep bailing out of chapters in the middle, and then trying the next chapter. I think I completely finished one chapter out of five or six, then I quit it.

Book Info

Author
Jorge Carrion
Year
Pages
295
Acquired
  • I have read this book. According to my records, I completed it on .
  • A softcover copy of this book is currently in my home library.

Here are some notes I took on the acquisition of this book:

Bought at City Lights in San Francisco

Links to this – Souk April 11, 2023
This is an Arabian term for open-air market. This would be the classic flea market or farmer’s market in the United States. This is stereotypically presented in every movie set in the Middle East as a place with a cacophony of smells, sounds, and visuals.
Links to this – Synecdoche April 11, 2023
This is a type of metonym. Specifically it’s when a smaller part of something is used to refer to the whole thing. When we say we need “boots on the ground,” we’re talking about entire humans, not just boots. The boots are just used as a shorthand for the larger concept. It’s pronounced...
Links to this – Putsch April 2, 2022
It’s a German word, and it might come from an Old Germanic term for “blow” or “strike.” The “u” sound is like “put” not “putt.”
Links from this – The French Art of Not Trying Too Hard December 26, 2022
I struggled with this book. I didn’t finish it, but I tried. I even tried to go back and read it in pieces. In fact, I kept it on my reading table for a week, picking it up over and over and try and make some sense of it. (The date on this review is simply the date when I gave up…) Here’s a problem...